Pear: Phobia at Edinburgh Fringe ★★★★★
★★★★★ Pear: Phobia | Underbelly Cowgate
An annoyingly great set from six-foot-seven identical twins Hugo and Patrick McPherson – whose career prospects surely have nothing to fear!
Double-acts throughout the land must be absolutely livid – because, of course, there can presumably be no bettering the twin-telepathy comedy timing that Pear are able to put to devastating effect. Returning to the fringe after three previous triumphs, there’s no sign that this is a novelty act running out of ideas – far from it, Phobia feels like the tightest, most-assured hour of sketch comedy at the Fringe this year.
There’s no easing in – Pear just hit the ground running and keep the laughs flowing for an exhausting hour. There’s something for everyone: seamless crowd work, cheeky asides, a handful of outrageously dark punchlines, some hilarious awkwardness, delightful awkwardness, and what at least feels like impressive improvisation.
The show has a neat concept – aiming to eliminate all fear – which organically permeates the series of well-honed routines. And though one could perhaps wish for a bit more rough around the edges, it would be churlish to criticise a show which just feels so well put together. Even the audience participation – a part of comedy shows which this reviewer often finds wince-inducing – is pulled off with aplomb, and it’s a sign of a great performer (or pair of performers) when the audience feels so at ease with what might be to come.
Which is not to say that there aren’t surprises by way of some excellent punchlines – the Diana joke is a thing of guffawing beauty, as are the repeat visits to group therapy – and very few of the sketches are telegraphed, so you’ll need your brain engaged as well as your eyes and ears. But this isn’t wanky too-smart-for-its-own-good comedy – Pear are mining a vein of comedy gold which is likely the envy of most of their rivals right now – and delivering with such impeccable timing and measured confidence that’s it hard to imagine they won’t outgrow the fringe in the very near future.
I am Joint Editor at To Do List. I like: nice pubs, film marathons, not doing real marathons, bad comedy, plays/musicals with shorter second halves, and the Oxford comma.
